SmallBizGenius Analysis
Tarte Cosmetics receives mixed feedback, with many customers praising the product quality but reporting significant issues with customer service and order fulfillment. While some customers have had consistently positive experiences, a significant number report problems that impact the overall perception of the brand.
Category Breakdown
Scores based on analysis of 200 recent reviews
Customer Service
3.0/10Many reviewers express dissatisfaction with Tarte's customer service, citing long response times, unhelpful or scripted replies, and difficulty resolving issues such as missing orders or refunds. Some customers even contacted Tarte's parent company, Kose corporation, to get their issues resolved.
42 reviews mention thisShipping & Delivery
3.5/10A significant number of reviewers report problems with shipping and delivery, including delayed orders, orders never arriving, and incorrect items being shipped. Some customers also mentioned paying for expedited shipping but not receiving it.
38 reviews mention thisProduct Quality
8.0/10Many customers praise the quality of Tarte's makeup and skincare products, particularly their mascaras and lip products. Some reviewers appreciate the company's commitment to cruelty-free ingredients.
25 reviews mention thisReturns & Refunds
2.0/10Several reviewers report difficulties in obtaining refunds for returned or missing items. Some customers claim they only received partial refunds or no refund at all, even after months of waiting.
18 reviews mention thisOrder Fulfillment
2.5/10Several customers report receiving incorrect items, missing items from their orders, or even fake products. This raises concerns about the company's order fulfillment processes and quality control.
22 reviews mention thisDiscount Codes & Promotions
4.0/10Some customers report issues with applying discount codes at checkout, leading to frustration and a feeling of being misled. Others mention that while the discounts are appealing, the issues with order fulfillment and customer service negate the value.
8 reviews mention thisPros & Cons
What Customers Love
"The mascaras are perfect, beautifully packaged and arrived exactly when the estimated delivery was."
"Since listening to the founder on the podcast "how i built this", I have been obsessed with Tarte as they have strong morals about the ingredients that are used in the products and being cruelty free"
"They often has good offers so everyone can effort it."
"I have ordered 3 times from Tarte and every order has arrived in about a week (USA-UK)"
"The mascaras are perfect, beautifully packaged and arrived exactly when the estimated delivery was."
Common Complaints
"Foreign customer service rep was completely ineffective and only repeated the same scripted lines. PATHETIC."
"Order never arrived. Contacted customer support and they could not provide an update."
"Tarte is the worst experience ever, customer service has taken months to refund and only refunded 1/4 of my return."
"Received an order after a month waiting but both items were incorrect."
"Received a clearly fake, cheap product from China having paid £35 for an under eye concealer."
Common Questions About Tarte Cosmetics
Answers derived from customer review patterns
Is tarte cosmetics legit and trustworthy?
Tarte Cosmetics is a real company, but the reviews indicate significant issues with order fulfillment and customer service. While some customers receive genuine products and have positive experiences, a substantial number report receiving incorrect, missing, or even fake items. The inconsistent service and product quality raise concerns about the company's reliability, making it essential for potential customers to proceed with caution and be prepared for potential issues.
Based on 45 reviewsDoes tarte cosmetics have good customer service?
Based on the reviews, Tarte Cosmetics' customer service is a major point of concern. Many customers describe long response times, unhelpful or scripted replies, and difficulty resolving issues such as missing orders or refunds. Some reviewers even had to contact Tarte's parent company to get their problems addressed, indicating a significant breakdown in their customer service processes. The negative feedback suggests that Tarte's customer service is often inadequate and frustrating for customers.
Based on 42 reviewsIs tarte cosmetics worth it for small business?
For small businesses, partnering with Tarte Cosmetics could be risky due to the reported issues with order fulfillment and customer service. The potential for delayed or missing orders, incorrect items, and difficulties in obtaining refunds could negatively impact a small business's operations and reputation. While the product quality is generally praised, the inconsistent service execution makes Tarte Cosmetics a less reliable choice for businesses that require consistent and dependable partnerships.
Based on 10 reviewsWhat is tarte cosmetics' return policy like?
The reviews suggest that Tarte Cosmetics' return policy is problematic in practice, despite what their official policy states. Several customers report difficulties in initiating returns, receiving return labels, or obtaining refunds for returned items. Some customers claim they only received partial refunds or no refund at all, even after months of waiting. This indicates a significant disconnect between the stated return policy and the actual customer experience.
Based on 18 reviewsWhy are customers receiving fake Tarte products?
Several reviewers report receiving what they believe to be fake or counterfeit Tarte products, often shipped from China. These items are described as being of poor quality, with cheap packaging and incorrect branding. It's unclear whether these products are being intentionally sold as genuine Tarte items or if they are the result of a supply chain issue. Customers should carefully inspect their orders upon arrival and contact Tarte immediately if they suspect they have received a fake product.
Based on 5 reviewsReady to Try Tarte Cosmetics?
Save on your first purchase with 5 verified coupon codes.
View CouponsLooking for Something Different?
Compare Tarte Cosmetics against 123 similar beauty & salon options.
View Alternatives